Loading

Got a version of Excel that uses the
ribbon interface (Excel 2007 or later)?
**This site is for you!** If you
use an earlier version of Excel, visit
our *ExcelTips* site focusing on the menu interface.

With more than 50 non-fiction books and numerous magazine articles to his credit, Allen Wyatt is an internationally recognized author. He is president of Sharon Parq Associates, a computer and publishing services company.

Learn more about Allen...

ExcelTips FAQ

ExcelTips Resources

Ask an Excel Question

Make a Comment

Free Business Forms

Free Calendars

** Please Note:** This article is written for users of the following Microsoft Excel versions: 2007, 2010, and 2013. If you are using an earlier version (Excel 2003 or earlier),

Pam has two columns of data. In column A there are simple identifiers, such as A, B, C, etc. In column B there are a series of integer values. She can sort the data by the identifier and, secondarily, by the integer values. Now she wants, in column C, to have a formula that will concatenate all the integer values for a particular identifier. Thus, if A1:A4 all contain the identifier A, then in cell C1 she would like to have all the values in B1:B4 concatenated and divided by commas, such as "11, 17, 19, 25". Since the number of rows for each identifier can be different, Pam isn't sure how to go about the concatenation.

The easiest way to accomplish this is to use a macro, which can be created as a user-defined function. Here's an example:

Function CatSame(c As Range) As String Application.Volatile sTemp = "" iCurCol = c.Column If iCurCol = 3 Then If c.Row = 1 Then sLast = "" Else sLast = c.Offset(-1, -2) End If If c.Offset(0, -2) <> sLast Then J = 0 Do sTemp = sTemp & ", " & c.Offset(J, -1) J = J + 1 Loop While c.Offset(J, -2) = c.Offset(J - 1, -2) sTemp = Right(sTemp, Len(sTemp) - 2) End If End If CatSame = sTemp End Function

This function basically takes a value that is passed to it (a cell reference) and verifies that the cell reference is for column C. If it is, then it starts to concatenate values from column B based on the values in column A. It only returns the string of concatenated values if the value is column A is different than the value in the row above it. Assuming your identifiers are in column A and your values to be concatenated are in column B, you could place the following in column C:

=CatSame(C1)

Copy this down as far as necessary in column C and you end up with exactly what Pam wanted.

A more versatile function would be one that would function somewhat like VLOOKUP, but bring back a concatenated list of values that match whatever you are looking up. Consider the following function:

Function VLookupAll(vValue, rngAll As Range, _ iCol As Integer, Optional sSep As String = ", ") Dim rCell As Range Dim rng As Range On Error GoTo ErrHandler Application.Volatile Set rng = Intersect(rngAll, rngAll.Columns(1)) For Each rCell In rng If rCell.Value = vValue Then _ VLookupAll = VLookupAll & sSep & _ rCell.Offset(0, iCol).Value Next rCell If VLookupAll = "" Then VLookupAll = CVErr(xlErrNA) Else VLookupAll = Right(VLookupAll, Len(VLookupAll) - Len(sSep)) End If ErrHandler: If Err.Number <> 0 Then VLookupAll = CVErr(xlErrValue) End Function

This function takes up to four arguments. The first is the value you want to match in your lookup. In Pam's instance, this would be the identifier you want, such as A, B, or C. The second argument is the range of cells in which to look for the matches (column A in this case). The third argument is an offset (from the range in the second argument) that represents the values you want concatenated. You can use the function in this manner:

=VLookupAll("B",A1:A99,1)

If you want to specify a different delimiter between values, you can do it using the optional fourth argument. For instance, the following returns a string where a dash separates each value:

=VLookupAll("B",A1:A99,1,"-")

The solutions so far have focused on using macros. The reason for this is relatively simple: There isn't a formula-based solution that can do what Pam needs. Using nested IF statements to evaluate what is in column A won't work well because you are limited in how deeply IF statements can be nested.

You could use a formula and an intermediate result if you don't mind having the concatenated values be at the last instance of an identifier in column A. Start by putting this formula in cell C1:

=B1

This formula should go into cell C2:

=IF(A2=A1,C1 & ", " & B2, B2)

Copy this formula down as many rows as necessary. What you end up with is an increasingly long series of concatenated values in column C, with the longest in each run being on the same row as the last sequential identifier in column A. You can then put the following in all the applicable cells of column D:

=IF(LEN(C2)>LEN(C1),"",C1)

This formula only displays the longest strings from column C, which is what Pam needed to begin with.

*ExcelTips* is your source for cost-effective Microsoft Excel training. This tip (9199) applies to Microsoft Excel 2007, 2010, and 2013. You can find a version of this tip for the older menu interface of Excel here: Concatenating Values from a Variable Number of Cells.

*Related Tips:*

**Program Successfully in Excel!** John Walkenbach's name is synonymous with excellence in deciphering complex technical topics. With this comprehensive guide, "Mr. Spreadsheet" shows how to maximize your Excel experience using professional spreadsheet application development tips from his own personal bookshelf. Check out *Excel 2013 Power Programming with VBA* today!

Sorry for a "small" TIPO.

In cell C2, the formula

should read:

=IF(COUNTIF(A$2:A2,A2)=1,Concat_Integers(A$2:A$16,A2),"")

--------------------------

Michael (Micky) Avidan

“Microsoft® Answers" - Wiki author & Forums Moderator

“Microsoft®” MVP – Excel (2009-2016)

ISRAEL

In cell C2, the formula

should read:

=IF(COUNTIF(A$2:A2,A2)=1,Concat_Integers(A$2:A$16,A2),"")

--------------------------

Michael (Micky) Avidan

“Microsoft® Answers" - Wiki author & Forums Moderator

“Microsoft®” MVP – Excel (2009-2016)

ISRAEL

@@@ To whom it may concern,

I would use a simpler approach as demonstrated in the linked picture:

http://postimg.org/image/7iwjzq21b

--------------------------

Michael (Micky) Avidan

“Microsoft® Answers" - Wiki author & Forums Moderator

“Microsoft®” MVP – Excel (2009-2016)

ISRAEL

I would use a simpler approach as demonstrated in the linked picture:

http://postimg.org/image/7iwjzq21b

--------------------------

Michael (Micky) Avidan

“Microsoft® Answers" - Wiki author & Forums Moderator

“Microsoft®” MVP – Excel (2009-2016)

ISRAEL

I've spent the last 2 days searching for a solution. It is a bit of a workaround & a few extra steps for what I wanted to do, but it works perfectly so no complaints.

Ok so I used your Catsame function and it works great. Now I want to do the same thing but instead of concat I want to simply sum all of the variable values together. Basically I want to use the Subtotal function, but I don't want to group each set of numbers using the built-in Subtotal button. I want the output to be in a new column just like the concat formula, but I only want to display the total one time per grouping of similar values. Any idea how to do this?

You sir are brilliant. Exactly what I needed and couldn't find anything outside of buggy Iserror/Small/Index functions. Thank you so much!